The idea that monetary and fiscal policy can and ought to be used to ameliorate the business cycle, to avoid the kind of boom/busts that lead to social instability and radical ideologies is a rather modern notion, and it remains somewhat controversial, according to Marc Chandler, Global Head of Currency Strategy at BBH.   

Key Quotes

“Many now see it as hubris that policymakers can tame the business cycle.   However, for those who subscribe, the general understanding is that policy ought to be counter-cyclical.”

“In a cyclical expansion, tax revenues are higher and social support funding, such as unemployment compensation, are lower.  Budget deficits ought to fall, and even Keynes' did not advocate a permanent deficit.  Some policymakers in the UK even formally thought about the budget balance over the course of entire business cycle.”

“In addition to the automatic stabilizers, governments may want to fill in the breech in private sector demand with new public spending--consumption and investment.  And indeed, many countries provided additional fiscal support to bolster aggregate demand in the 2008-2009 period.”

“Monetary policy is supposed to work the same way.  The longest-serving Chair of the Federal Reserve was William McChesney Martin (1951-1970).  He had to resist the pressure from President Johnson who wanted easier monetary policy.  Martin explained how the central bank needed to "lean against the wind" of inflation and that the Fed's jobs was to "take away the punch bowl just as the party gets going."   This too has become part of the inherited wisdom.”

“The problem, it seems, is that policy may be becoming pro-cyclical.  Many are critical of the fiscal stimulus the US is providing through tax cuts and spending increases while the economy continues to grow above trend.  It produces a large deficit and increases the US debt burden, but even those who accept the need for public investment have serious reservations about the magnitude of the fiscal stimulus now.”

“Given that the US economic recovery began in 2009, it is not surprising that it is increasing displaying late-cycle characteristics, even if the fiscal stimulus gooses the economy a bit this year. We have loosely anticipated a growth recession if not an outright contraction in late 2019 or 2020.  The cyclical expansion in the budget deficit will begin from a higher level, as will US debt levels.  The price to pay for the pro-cyclical fiscal stimulus now will be higher debt and likely higher interest rates later.”

“Europe may find itself in a similar position.  Under reform fatigue, several countries appear poised to increase fiscal support, including Germany (if the SPD approve the new Grand Coalition) and Italy (depending on next month's election outcome).”

“The recent string of surveys from Europe suggest that the economic momentum may have peaked at the end of last year.   To be sure, this does not mean the end of the business cycle is around the corner, but by the time the ECB raises rates, likely around the middle of 2019, the risk is that the regional economy would have already begun slowing.  If the goal is to lengthen the duration and lower the amplitude of the business cycle, a pro-cyclical monetary policy would threaten the opposite.”

“The Bank of Canada hiked rates in July and September last year.  In the H1 2017, Canada's monthly GDP rose 0.4%.  In the next five months, the average monthly GDP edged 0.1% higher.  The estimate for December will be released next week along with Q4 GDP.   Growth in Q3 slowed to 1.7% annualized pace.  It was the slowest since the unexpected contraction in Q2 16.  The Bank of Canada became the first major central bank to hike rates this year.   After that hike was delivered the market quickly discounted more than a 50% chance of a follow-up hike in April.”

“The risk is that the Bank of Canada continues to remove accommodation as the economy softens. Although Canadian retail sales were a major disappointment today falling 0.8% and dropping 1.8% when auto sales are excluded, it is consistent with 2017 being a year of two halves for Canada-strong in the first half, weaker in the second.”

“Japan has been unable to exit its extraordinary policies despite among the longest modern expansion.  Monetary policy appears still be open spigot even though the pace of the BOJ's balance sheet expansion has slowed as it augments its QQE with yield curve management.  Fiscal policy has been expansionary.  The deficit stood at 5.0% of GDP last year, down from 5.7% in 2016.  With the BOJ's massive holdings of government bonds, a financial crisis over Japan's debt seems remote.  That said, the path seems unsustainable and long-term investors recognize that.”

“Next year, Japan is slated to raise the retail sales tax (from 8% to 10%).  The risk is that that Japanese economy is slowing when the tax which has been postpone a couple of times.  Japan's Prime Minister is loath of postpone it again, after running last year's campaign against an opposition party that wanted to cancel the sales tax increase.  Abe has conceded that part of the funds raised will be used for tax cuts rather than debt reduction, which had been the original intent.”

“Although the world enjoys a synchronized expansion, the Great Financial Crisis may not be truly over until the downside of this business cycle is managed. Pro-cyclical monetary and fiscal policies exacerbate the challenge that lies ahead for investors and policymakers.”

Share: Feed news

Information on these pages contains forward-looking statements that involve risks and uncertainties. Markets and instruments profiled on this page are for informational purposes only and should not in any way come across as a recommendation to buy or sell in these assets. You should do your own thorough research before making any investment decisions. FXStreet does not in any way guarantee that this information is free from mistakes, errors, or material misstatements. It also does not guarantee that this information is of a timely nature. Investing in Open Markets involves a great deal of risk, including the loss of all or a portion of your investment, as well as emotional distress. All risks, losses and costs associated with investing, including total loss of principal, are your responsibility. The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of FXStreet nor its advertisers. The author will not be held responsible for information that is found at the end of links posted on this page.

If not otherwise explicitly mentioned in the body of the article, at the time of writing, the author has no position in any stock mentioned in this article and no business relationship with any company mentioned. The author has not received compensation for writing this article, other than from FXStreet.

FXStreet and the author do not provide personalized recommendations. The author makes no representations as to the accuracy, completeness, or suitability of this information. FXStreet and the author will not be liable for any errors, omissions or any losses, injuries or damages arising from this information and its display or use. Errors and omissions excepted.

The author and FXStreet are not registered investment advisors and nothing in this article is intended to be investment advice.

Recommended content


Recommended content

Editors’ Picks

GBP/USD extends recovery gains to near 1.3250, as BoE looms

GBP/USD extends recovery gains to near 1.3250, as BoE looms

GBP/USD extends the recovery to near 1.3200 in European trading on Thursday, having found buyers near 1.3150. A fresh US Dollar pullback and a rebound in risk sentiment offer support to the pair ahead of the BoE policy announcements. 

GBP/USD News
EUR/USD advances to 1.1150, focus shifts to ECB-speak

EUR/USD advances to 1.1150, focus shifts to ECB-speak

EUR/USD is well-bid near 1.1150 in the European session on Thursday. The pair is underpinned by the renewed US Dollar retreat and an upbeat mood. Traders digest the Fed's dovish outlook, bracing for ECB-speak for fresh trading incentives. US data are also eyed. 

EUR/USD News
Gold price jumps back closer to all-time peak, $2,600 remains in sight amid fresh USD weakness

Gold price jumps back closer to all-time peak, $2,600 remains in sight amid fresh USD weakness

Gold price regains positive traction following the previous day's pullback from the all-time peak and builds on its steady intraday ascent heading into the European session on Thursday. 

Gold News
BoE expected to keep interest rate unchanged at 5% as price pressures persist

BoE expected to keep interest rate unchanged at 5% as price pressures persist

After a close call in August, the Bank of England’s September interest rate decision is keenly awaited for fresh cues on the bank’s future policy action and the pace of its bond sales.

Read more
Bitcoin surges to $62,000 mark after 50 bps Fed rate cut

Bitcoin surges to $62,000 mark after 50 bps Fed rate cut

Bitcoin and Ripple eye for a rally as they break and find support around their resistance barrier. Meanwhile, Ethereum demonstrates signs of recovery as it approaches a critical resistance level, indicating that an upward rally could be on the horizon if it successfully breaks through.

Read more
Moneta Markets review 2024: All you need to know

Moneta Markets review 2024: All you need to know

VERIFIED In this review, the FXStreet team provides an independent and thorough analysis based on direct testing and real experiences with Moneta Markets – an excellent broker for novice to intermediate forex traders who want to broaden their knowledge base.

Read More

Forex MAJORS

Cryptocurrencies

Signatures