The other day @donnelly_brent  the author of Alpha Trader and a must follow on Twitter made the following observation, ”In trading, there are times when you should take positions so big they make you feel uncomfortable.

But still in control.

You need to be able to drive the car fast enough to win … But not so fast that you slam into a wall.

Do you generally trade too big, or too small?”

I thought this was an interesting take and a great question because it contains an underlying assumption that many miss. Do you trade discretionary or systematically? If the former, then absolutely Brent is right, if the latter then I think the complete opposite is true.

DIscretionary traders are trading narrative. Most of the time that narrative is fundamental in nature but it can also be technical. The point is that they are trading a very specific  story and depending on their level of confidence in the story they should size up accordingly, because  great stories are rare and the opportunities are few.

The all-time champ of discretionary trading is George Soros who once famously noted that, ““It's not whether you're right or wrong, but how much money you make when you're right and how much you lose when you're wrong.” Soros of course was wrong a lot, but his single greatest talent  was to bet huge when he was right. The quintessential example of that style was the British Pound trade when Soros made one billion dollars ( back when a billion really meant something) in a matter of a few weeks.

Soros was the ultimate probative trader he would poke and poke the market to test his thesis and if the price would go his way he would press the trade with all his might. In the pound battle against the Bank of  England, Soros’s fund bet the whole year's profits on that one position and came out a trading legend as result.

However, if you are a systematic trader like yours truly the Soros way is probably the fastest route to ruin. That is because systematic trading tries to capture a completely different edge. Instead of being driven by narrative, systematic trading focuses on market behavior. The idea is that certain types of patterns are so repetitive and predictable that a systematic approach  can carve out a positive stream of profits if you can wrap proper stops and targets around the trade.

I trade one primary systematic idea - namely that price will often reverse from sessions highs and lows. There is of course a lot more to it than that, but the basic premise is that in auction based markets mean reversion is far more common than continuity and you can exploit that dynamic if you can structure the setup properly. My setup is traded with a 1:1 risk reward ratio so I only need to be 51% right to have a positive edge. 

You should think of systematic trades as  factory produced donuts  that taste the same - unlike discretionary trades which can be sublime or inedible depending on the day.  Therefore it's much better to trade systematic strategies with uniform size. In fact I would argue that trading smaller rather than bigger is always an advantage with systematic trading because often the donut batch can become spoiled (probabilities change in different regimes) and it is much easier to absorb such losses and make proper adjustments when your inventory losses (your equity drawdown) is relatively modest.

Systematic approach relies on the law of large numbers and therefore requires small size to capture a small edge. There is a reason that Ken Griffin's Citadel trades 100 shares of stock a billion times a day for a tenth of a penny and 51% win rate and still makes billions of dollars a year. But that is a far cry  from making a billion dollars on one well placed macro bet as done by Soros.  Retail traders rarely understand the difference between the two and in their chase of profit often make the dangerous mistake of trading systematic ideas with a discretionary size.


Past performance is not indicative of future results. Trading forex carries a high level of risk, and may not be suitable for all investors. The high degree of leverage can work against you as well as for you. Before deciding to trade any such leveraged products you should carefully consider your investment objectives, level of experience, and risk appetite. The possibility exists that you could sustain a loss of some or all of your initial investment and therefore you should not invest money that you cannot afford to lose. You should be aware of all the risks associated with trading on margin, and seek advice from an independent financial advisor if you have any doubts.

Editors’ Picks

EUR/USD bounces off lows, retests 1.1370

EUR/USD bounces off lows, retests 1.1370

Following an early drop to the vicinity of 1.1310, EUR/USD now manages to regain pace and retargets the 1.1370-1.1380 band on the back of a tepid knee-jerk in the US Dollar, always amid growing optimism over a potential de-escalation in the US-China trade war.

EUR/USD News
GBP/USD trades slightly on the defensive in the low-1.3300s

GBP/USD trades slightly on the defensive in the low-1.3300s

GBP/USD remains under a mild selling pressure just above 1.3300 on Friday, despite firmer-than-expected UK Retail Sales. The pair is weighed down by a renewed buying interest in the Greenback, bolstered by fresh headlines suggesting a softening in the rhetoric surrounding the US-China trade conflict.

GBP/USD News
USD/JPY sets for positive weekly close above 143.00 as US Dollar rebounds

USD/JPY sets for positive weekly close above 143.00 as US Dollar rebounds

USD/JPY eyes a positive weekly close as the US Dollar (USD) bounces back. The US Dollar recovers as Trump has expressed confidence that he is close to making trade deals with number of trading partners. China denies having any trade negotiations with the US.

USD/JPY News

Editors’ Picks

EUR/USD bounces off lows, retests 1.1370

EUR/USD bounces off lows, retests 1.1370

Following an early drop to the vicinity of 1.1310, EUR/USD now manages to regain pace and retargets the 1.1370-1.1380 band on the back of a tepid knee-jerk in the US Dollar, always amid growing optimism over a potential de-escalation in the US-China trade war.

EUR/USD News
GBP/USD trades slightly on the defensive in the low-1.3300s

GBP/USD trades slightly on the defensive in the low-1.3300s

GBP/USD remains under a mild selling pressure just above 1.3300 on Friday, despite firmer-than-expected UK Retail Sales. The pair is weighed down by a renewed buying interest in the Greenback, bolstered by fresh headlines suggesting a softening in the rhetoric surrounding the US-China trade conflict.

GBP/USD News
Gold remains offered below $3,300

Gold remains offered below $3,300

Gold reversed Thursday’s rebound and slipped toward the $3,260 area per troy ounce at the end of the week in response to further improvement in the market sentiment, which was in turn underpinned by hopes of positive developments around the US-China trade crisis.

Gold News
Ethereum: Accumulation addresses grab 1.11 million ETH as bullish momentum rises

Ethereum: Accumulation addresses grab 1.11 million ETH as bullish momentum rises

Ethereum saw a 1% decline on Friday as sellers dominated exchange activity in the past 24 hours. Despite the recent selling, increased inflows into accumulation addresses and declining net taker volume show a gradual return of bullish momentum.

Read more
Week ahead: US GDP, inflation and jobs in focus amid tariff mess – BoJ meets

Week ahead: US GDP, inflation and jobs in focus amid tariff mess – BoJ meets

Barrage of US data to shed light on US economy as tariff war heats up. GDP, PCE inflation and nonfarm payrolls reports to headline the week. Bank of Japan to hold rates but may downgrade growth outlook. Eurozone and Australian CPI also on the agenda, Canadians go to the polls.

Read more

RECOMMENDED LESSONS

7 Ways to Avoid Forex Scams

The forex industry is recently seeing more and more scams. Here are 7 ways to avoid losing your money in such scams: Forex scams are becoming frequent. Michael Greenberg reports on luxurious expenses, including a submarine bought from the money taken from forex traders. Here’s another report of a forex fraud. So, how can we avoid falling in such forex scams?

What Are the 10 Fatal Mistakes Traders Make

Trading is exciting. Trading is hard. Trading is extremely hard. Some say that it takes more than 10,000 hours to master. Others believe that trading is the way to quick riches. They might be both wrong. What is important to know that no matter how experienced you are, mistakes will be part of the trading process.

The Best brokers to trade EUR/USD

The Best brokers to trade EUR/USD

SPONSORED Discover the top brokers for trading EUR/USD in 2025. Our list features brokers with competitive spreads, fast execution, and powerful platforms. Whether you're a beginner or an expert, find the right partner to navigate the dynamic Forex market.

Read More

Strategy

Money Management

Psychology

Best Brokers of 2025