"I had a buddy who picked a perfect bracket two years in a row! He went back and looked at the players' high school stats and everything!"

I was on a college trip with our investing club with that guy. You know the kind, the dreaded "One-Upper":

...If you had a friend who got a perfect score on a college entrance exam, Mr. One-Upper had done it himself...in middle school.

...If you went on a helicopter ride on a family trip to Hawaii, his uncle had invented the helicopter...and then used it to discover Hawaii.

...And as I had just found out, if you had once correctly picked 15 of the first 16 games of the NCAA basketball tournament, he had a buddy who put your "accomplishment" to shame.

He was, of course, either lying or badly misinformed. But his assertion gets at the most fundamental reason that its possible, though far from easy, for some traders and investors to earn market-beating returns.

For those who are not familiar, the NCAA college basketball tournament, colloquially dubbed "March Madness," has resumed its annual tradition of taking over the computer screens and attentions spans of Americans. According to a study by consultancy Challenger, Gray & Christmas, the act of filling out the brackets, checking scores, at outright watching the games at work costs US employers upwards of $4 Billion in lost productivity each year.

And if you've ever created your own bracket, you know that there's one emotion that quickly comes to dominate all others: regret. If only you had done a bit more research into the free throw shooting percentages of that team or the propensity for this team to struggle against zone defense, then you would have seen that upset coming.

And it's a fool's errand. At some point, the relationship between the sophistication of your analysis and the likelihood of success breaks down. The role of lucky and randomness takes over.

The world's most renowned investor, Warren Buffett, famously offered a cool $1B to anyone who filled out a perfect bracket. The oft-cited odds of correctly picking 63 consecutive games is 1 in 9,200,000,000,000,000,000, though the experts at FiveThirtyEight suggest that the actual odds are "only" 1 in about 1,500,000,000 most years. The point is that, even if you deeply researched the players' high school stats, as Mr. One Upper's friend ostensibly did, there are too many random variables to correctly predict every game...much less to do it consecutively!

The best you can hope for is a bracket that identifies potentially vulnerable favorites, underseeded upsets and correctly selects the champion. This is the same exact type of attitude that you should adopt with your trading. With all the economic, political, and technical crosscurrents that buffet the market every day, it's impossible to design a trading or investing strategy that wins 100% of its trades...even if you research the CEO's high school math grades!

James O'Shaughnessy, who quite literally wrote the book on investing strategy (What Works on Wall Street), recently opined on a similar topic. He studied the historic probability of Warren Buffett's Berkshire Hathaway (BRK.B), which we know in hindsight has been one of the greatest stocks of all-time,  outperforming the overall stock market over different time periods:

Rolling

Obviously, Buffett's track record is stellar, but even "The Oracle of Omaha" has had a greater than 1 in four shot of underperforming the overall stock market in any given year. Indeed, BRK.B has trailed the stock market over a five-year basis  nearly 10% of the time.

Imagine where you were five years ago. Now imagine that your favorite investment had underperformed a simple, stupid S&P 500 index fund over those last five years. Would you have the confidence and temerity to stick with that investment? Chances are many of Buffett's "long-term" investors jumped ship during these periods of underperformance, which was in hindsight, one of the worst things they could do.

Don't fall into Mr. One-Upper's trap of thinking you can pick the perfect bracket or the perfect trading/investing strategy. The best you can hope for is a consistent process that identifies higher-probability outcomes for your timeframe, limits risk in the (inevitable) event that the market moves against you, and the discipline to stick to your strategy even when it temporarily underperforms.

We might not have quite as long of a track record as Warren Buffett, but that's exactly what we at Faraday Research have been doing for years...just don't ask us for help with your bracket!

This research is for informational purposes and should not be construed as personal advice. Trading any financial market involves risk. Trading on leverage involves risk of losses greater than deposits.

Education feed

Editors’ Picks

EUR/USD trades around 1.09 amid upbeat German data, thin liquidity

EUR/USD is trading around 1.09 as ongoing SIno-American tensions boost the safe-haven US dollar. The German IFO figures for May beat expectations with 79.5 points in May. Coronavirus figures in Europe are declining.

EUR/USD News

GBP/USD is trading below 1.22 amid negative rates speculation

GBP/USD is trading below 1.22, as investors continue speculating about the BOE setting negative rates. PM Johnson is under pressure after his senior adviser violated the lockdown. The UK is on a bank holiday today.

GBP/USD News

USD/JPY clings to gains near 50-day SMA, bulls await a move beyond 108.00 mark

USD/JPY regains some positive traction on Monday amid a positive mood around equity markets. Concerns about worsening US-China tensions seemed to be the only factor capping further gains. Sustained move beyond 50-day SMA, 108.00 mark needed to confirm any near-term bullish bias.

USD/JPY News

Editors’ Picks

EUR/USD trades around 1.09 amid upbeat German data, thin liquidity

EUR/USD is trading around 1.09 as ongoing SIno-American tensions boost the safe-haven US dollar. The German IFO figures for May beat expectations with 79.5 points in May. Coronavirus figures in Europe are declining.

EUR/USD News

GBP/USD is trading below 1.22 amid negative rates speculation

GBP/USD is trading below 1.22, as investors continue speculating about the BOE setting negative rates. PM Johnson is under pressure after his senior adviser violated the lockdown. The UK is on a bank holiday today.

GBP/USD News

USD/JPY clings to gains near 50-day SMA, bulls await a move beyond 108.00 mark

USD/JPY regains some positive traction on Monday amid a positive mood around equity markets. Concerns about worsening US-China tensions seemed to be the only factor capping further gains. Sustained move beyond 50-day SMA, 108.00 mark needed to confirm any near-term bullish bias.

USD/JPY News

Forex Today: Dollar in demand amid high Sino-American tensions, thin liquidity expected

The new week has kicked off with dollar strength as the US and China have kept tensions high. Thin liquidity and potential erratic movements may occur as the United States and United Kingdom are on holiday.

Read more

Gold trades with modest losses, holds above $1722 support zone

Gold met with some fresh supply on Monday, albeit lacked any strong follow-through selling and was last seen trading with only modest losses, just below $1730 level.

Gold News

RECOMMENDED LESSONS

7 Ways to Avoid Forex Scams

The forex industry is recently seeing more and more scams. Here are 7 ways to avoid losing your money in such scams: Forex scams are becoming frequent. Michael Greenberg reports on luxurious expenses, including a submarine bought from the money taken from forex traders. Here’s another report of a forex fraud. So, how can we avoid falling in such forex scams?

What Are the 10 Fatal Mistakes Traders Make

Trading is exciting. Trading is hard. Trading is extremely hard. Some say that it takes more than 10,000 hours to master. Others believe that trading is the way to quick riches. They might be both wrong. What is important to know that no matter how experienced you are, mistakes will be part of the trading process.

Strategy

Money Management

Psychology