|

Dealing desk or no dealing desk?

Dealing desk or no dealing desk?

That is not the question, it’s what you need to know.

For years, one of the main things to keep in mind when choosing a brokerage, was whether the broker operated with a dealing desk or without one. Choosing one type of broker over another was somewhat simple and understanding the trade structure of a broker and making a decision on who to go with, only depended on how comfortable a trader felt with the level of risk provided.

Basically, dealing desk brokers, also known as market makers, offer fixed spreads and simulated quotes, and are defined by the fact that they take the opposite side of a trader's trade and fill orders on a discretionary basis. No dealing desk, otherwise known as straight through processing (STPs) brokers on the contrary, have variable spreads on most cases, quote prices directly from liquidity providers, serve only as a connector between a trader and the liquidity provider, and fill orders automatically, without re-quoting.

Having this in mind, day traders typically chose the tighter spreads, while long term traders preferred wider spreads.

In recent times however, corporate synergy in the risk management and prime brokerage sector, as well as numerous mergers and acquisitions between large brokerages and liquidity providers, have made things less clear than crystal.

As recent as last month, one of the US’ largest Forex firms, FXCM, ceased operations in the USA after the NFA filed a complaint accusing the broker of routing orders of the no dealing desk model, through a dealing desk served largely by liquidity provider Effex Capital, a firm that although represented as an independent entity, was in fact controlled by FXCM.

Dealing desk brokers are not all bad however. The main reasons why traders don’t feel comfortable with using money managers, are firstly, the fact that often times, the broker is on the other side of the transaction taken by the trader, actively trading against the trader, causing a significant conflict of interest (your broker essentially makes money when you lose). Secondly, you may see delays in getting your orders filled, since every order needs to be approved manually. In times of high volatility, a delay in getting your order actioned may mean a slip of a few dozen pips. In an ideal FX universe however,  a  market maker should be indifferent to the decisions of an individual trader, since they fill both the buy and sell quote for clients.

Once upon a time, deciding for one brokerage over another based on the type of trading structure they offered may have been all a trader cared about, but today, with the landscape of the industry changing as rapidly as currency prices do, and the Forex sector holding a reputation tainted by some companies’ grift, things are not as black and white as they once were. Today, to ensure that what a brokerage is promising is in fact what it is delivering when it comes to its trading system, traders would be wise to read not only the fine print, but also to read between the lines. 

Author

Adinah Brown

Adinah Brown

Leverate

More from Adinah Brown
Share:

Editor's Picks

Bitcoin slips below $60,000 as selling pressure accelerates

Bitcoin price falls below the $60,000 mark on Friday, down nearly 8.5% so far this week and reaching a level not seen since early July. Market momentum suggests firm selling pressure despite reaching oversold levels, with technical indicators pointing to further downside toward the yearly low of $57,800.

Ethereum falters as returning retail demand fails to offset ETF outflows

Ethereum continues to face intense headwinds, trading below $1,750 on Friday. Broadly, the smart contract token is down about 6% since Monday and 23% from November 1. This persistent pullback can largely be attributed to risk-off sentiment following the Binance hack, macroeconomic pressures including sticky US inflation, and a lack of catalysts to sustain higher crypto prices.

Ripple fails to reclaim $1.00 despite supply shortage on Binance

Ripple trades around $0.96 on Friday, positioned between the lower range limit at $0.90 and the upper range limit at $1.00. The remittance token recently failed to advance above the critical $1.00 level, leaving bears largely in control. Nonetheless, bulls appear not ready to give up, increasing buy-the-dip activity toward the $0.90 zone.

Crypto market retreats to $2.11T, following stocks
Crypto market capitalisation fell 2% over the past 24 hours to $2.11T, dipping to $2.1T at its low. This marks a return to the mid-summer lows, when the market bottomed out at $2.06T. A sudden downturn in stocks and metals shortly after the start of active trading in New York sent Nasdaq-100 futures down 5.7% from Thursday's intraday high to a daily low at 6:30 GMT on Friday.
Bitcoin: Storm not yet over
Bitcoin (BTC) extends its losing streak, dropping to $61,222 on Friday and heading toward a seventh consecutive week of losses as bearish pressure grips the broader crypto market. Persistent institutional outflows and leveraged liquidations are keeping BTC under pressure, while the hawkish tone of the Federal Reserve (Fed) leaves Crypto King vulnerable to further downside.