NFP Quick Analysis: Three reasons why the worst jobs report is even uglier, market implications

  • The crash in the participation rate shows that many more are out of the workforce.
  • The real unemployment rate is higher, at 22.8%. 
  • BLS admits underreporting which is worth another five percentage points. 

The worst Non-Farm Payrolls report in history – 20.5 jobs lost and an unemployment rate of 14.7% – is shocking but investors were already bracing for disaster. The lockdowns imposed to curb the spread of coronavirus have taken their toll. The headline figures are devastating, but other statistics already paint an even darker picture.

Follow Non-Farm Payrolls updates live

1) Crash in participation

The participation rate had already tumbled from 63.4% to 62.7% in March and has now extended its fall to 60.2%. That means that the calculation of the unemployment rate is skewed to the upside. When fewer of those out of work are counted as unemployed, the percentage is lower. 

Will they come back? That is an open question.

2) The real unemployment rate is higher

Better estimates include the U-6 or "real unemployment rate – which had already leaped to 8.7% in March and is now 22.8% – and the broadest measure, the employment to population ratio, which stood at 60% in March and is now only 51.3%

3) Underreporting 

Even when disregarding that U-6 "real unemployment rate, the Bureau of Labor Statistics which publishes the NFP has this to note, emphasis mine:

If the workers who were recorded as employed but absent from work due to "other reasons" (over  and above the number absent for other reasons in a typical April) had been classified as unemployed on temporary layoff, the overall unemployment rate would have been almost 5 percentage points higher than reported

That means that the headline could have been 19.7% and not 14.7%. Taking the previous figures into account, things look dire.

Market implications

Traders had their tin hats on, bracing for horrible figures. The details are worse and imply the situation is far worse. Stocks may suffer from deteriorating prospects for the US and global economies. 

The safe-haven US dollar has room to rise – when the US coughs, the world catches a severe sickness. 

S&P 500: Five charts to explain the comeback and why coronavirus carnage may crash it again

More information: 

US jobs report post-release checklist – May 8th, 2020

NFP Actual, Consensus and Deviation Negative The "worst US job report ever" printed a headline 20.5M job loss. Even if better than the -22M expected, it is a dismal figure.
NFP Revisions Negative March job growth number was revised downwards, from -701K to -870K.
Unemployment rate Negative

U3 unemployment rate spiked from 4.4% to 14.7%, while U6 underemployment skyrocketed from 8.7% to 22.8%.

Labor Force Participation Rate Negative The share of people in the workforce plunged from 62.7% to 60.2%, way below expectations.
Average Hourly Earnings Positive The layoffs are mostly being on lower-income jobs, as average wages figures have climbed above the roof to 4.7% on the month and 7.9% in yearly terms.


Foreign exchange (forex) trading carries a high level of risk and may not be suitable for all investors. The risk grows as the leverage is higher.
investment objectives, risk appetite and the trader’ level of experience should be carefully weighed before entering the forex market. There is always a possibility of losing some or all of your initial investment / deposit, so you should not invest money which is which it can’t afford to lose. The high risk that is involved with currency trading must be known to you. Please ask for advice from an independent financial advisor before entering this market.

Any comments made on Forex Crunch or on other sites that have received permission to republish the content originating on Forex Crunch reflect the opinions of the individual authors and do not necessarily represent the opinions of any of Forex Crunch’s authorized authors. Forex Crunch has not verified the accuracy or basis-in-fact of any claim or statement made by any independent author: Omissions and errors may occur.
Any news, analysis, opinion, price quote or any other information contained on Forex Crunch and permitted re-published content should be taken as general market commentary. This is by no means investment advice. Forex Crunch will not accept liability for any damage, loss, including without limitation to, any profit loss, which may either arise directly or indirectly from use of such information.

Analysis feed

FXStreet Trading Signals now available!

Access to real-time signals, community and guidance now!

Latest Forex Analysis

Editors’ Picks

EUR/USD moves closer to 1.1100 amid upbeat market mood

EUR/USD is trading well above 1.1050, hitting new 8-week highs. US data was mixed with a ray of light coming from continuing claims. Hopes about the EU Fund and reopenings trump Sino-American relations.


AUD/USD retreats ahead of the close as US equities turn red

After spending most of the day within positive levels, US indexes turned south ahead of the close, dragging the Aussie alongside. AUD/USD still up for the day in the 0.6630 price zone.


Goldman Sachs puts Bitcoin on par with Gold

One of the world's largest investment banks, Goldman Sachs, announced a conference for its clients entitled “Implications of Current Inflation, Gold and Bitcoin Policies”

Read more

Gold: Limited gains below the $1730/oz level for XAU/USD

After bouncing from the 1690/1700 price zone XAU/USD is stalling below the 1730 resistance and the 50 SMA on the four chart. The picture is mixed as it seems the metal is challenging a tough resistance near the 1730 level.

Gold News

WTI oil prices rally on gasoline demand and hopes of output cuts’ extension

WTI crude oil prices have appreciated more than 5% on Thursday to reach $34 and approach two-month highs. Investors' optimism about an increase of gasoline demand and speculation of an OPEC+ deal to extend output cuts are driving crude prices higher.

Oil News

Forex Majors