China could be covering up true number of Coronavirus mortalities

Editor's note: This piece is based on the individual conjectures of the author and doesn't represent FXStreet's view. 

  • While China's Coronavirus (CoV) death toll rises to at least 80 from 56, China could be covering up the true picture to avoid a panic.
  • The WSJ and NYT reported on events which could raise questions over the real number of infections and contagion.
  • Risk-off flows weighing on equity futures and supporting the yen in Asia.

While China's Coronavirus (CoV) death toll rises to at least 80 from 56, with 2744 confirmed cases, there are some reports that allude to the possibility that China could be suppressing the full extent of CoV's lethality by keeping the mortality rate of the coronavirus artificially low. It may appear to some that there is an underlying incentive to underreport the true extent of the epidemic for as long as possible to avoid a panic.

Casting minds back to 2003, from an article written in the New York Times, it was reported that a Chinese doctor exposed the cover-up of China’s SARS outbreak. Dr. Jiang disclosed in a letter circulated to international news organizations that at least 100 people were being treated in Beijing hospitals for severe acute respiratory syndrome, or SARS. At the time, the Chinese medical authorities were asserting that the entire nation had only a handful of cases of the disease. The revelation prompted China’s top leaders to acknowledge that they had provided false information about the epidemic. The health minister and the mayor of Beijing were removed from their posts.

This time around, in a news written by the Wall Street Journal, (WSJ), it is stated that instead of putting down Coronavirus as the cause of death for an unknown number of Wuhan casualties, China's coroners and hospitals merely ascribe some death to "viral pneumonia":

A 53-year-old fitness trainer died on Wednesday after checking into a hospital in Wuhan a little more than a week earlier, said his niece. His family had expected the death certificate to reflect the deadly coronavirus, because as his condition deteriorated, his doctors told his family he was suffering from an untreatable virus in his lungs. Instead, it recorded “severe pneumonia” as the cause of death, she said. The relatives of two other people who died in separate hospitals in Wuhan this week also described similar situations, saying the causes of death had been given as “viral pneumonia,”

– reported in the WSJ, which gives us an insight into how China could be keeping the mortality rate of the coronavirus artificially low to void a panic:

"There are likely to be many times more cases in Wuhan than officially confirmed,” said Neil Ferguson, a disease modeller at Imperial College London, estimating as many as 4,000 people may have been infected in Wuhan. 

If this was the case, the forecast of a UK expert, (Dr Jonathan Read), on the transmission and evolutionary dynamics of infectious diseases which was recently published in a paper and read, "our model predicts the number of infected people in Wuhan to be greater than 250,000 (prediction interval, 164,602 to 351,396)," could be seriously underestimated.  Dr Jonathan Read said an explosion in the number of cases is less than two weeks away. 

Market implications

US S&P 500 futures are falling more than 1 pct in Asian trade on worries about CoV and USD/JPY dropped below the 109 handle. 


Information on these pages contains forward-looking statements that involve risks and uncertainties. Markets and instruments profiled on this page are for informational purposes only and should not in any way come across as a recommendation to buy or sell in these assets. You should do your own thorough research before making any investment decisions. FXStreet does not in any way guarantee that this information is free from mistakes, errors, or material misstatements. It also does not guarantee that this information is of a timely nature. Investing in Open Markets involves a great deal of risk, including the loss of all or a portion of your investment, as well as emotional distress. All risks, losses and costs associated with investing, including total loss of principal, are your responsibility. The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of FXStreet nor its advertisers.

Feed news

Latest Forex News

Latest Forex News

Editors’ Picks

AUD/USD: Bears attack 0.7700 ahead of China GDP

AUD/USD extends Friday’s downbeat momentum towards the 0.7700 threshold at the start of Monday’s Asian session. The Aussie pair declined the most since late October the previous day as the US dollar benefitted from the risk-off mood.


GBP/USD: Further restrictions in the UK may hit the pound

The GBP/USD pair trimmed most of its weekly gains on Friday and settled in the 1.3580 price zone, amid risk-off fueling dollar’s demand. UK GDP contracted by less than anticipated in November, Industrial Production plunged.


Gold: Further decline toward $1,800 remains on the cards

Gold failed to stage a convincing rebound this week. After losing more than 2% in the previous week, the XAU/USD pair extended its slide on Monday and touched its lowest level since early December at $1,817. 

Gold news

Darkest before dawn

The upcoming economic news is likely to be dreadful, and if it is not dreadful, it will be mostly ignored. This includes the release of the preliminary January PMI figures at the end of the week. Japan is extending its national emergency to another five prefectures, which collectively account for over half of the nation's GDP.

Read more

DXY breaks above key downtrend, eyes move above 91.00

USD has been strongly supported on what has shaped up to be a very much risk off final trading day of the week. Most G10/USD pairs have seen significant weakness, aside from CHF/USD and JPY/USD, given that the two currencies are also considered “safe havens”.

US Dollar Index News