|

Could Silver “do a Palladium”?

Palladium was manipulated for years. It had the largest short position relative to its size, while physical demand rose inversely to decreasing supply.

In 2018, demand became so large that it overwhelmed the shorts.

Physical palladium could not meet the market's needs and prices exploded. Shorts eventually decreased their positions until they got to a more sustainable level.

For many years, the platinum/palladium ratio, shown on proprietary charts, averaged 2.4 to 1 in favor of platinum, stretched as high as 5:1 in 2009, but then collapsed for a decade into 2020, to where 1 ounce of palladium would buy 5 ounces of platinum!

Today, much like what was the case with palladium, the concentrated short position in silver is unsustainable.

Ted Butler has been writing about it for two decades, and we can be forgiven for thinking it will never change. But at some point soon, it appears the shorts WILL be overwhelmed.

Indeed, the rats are already leaving the sinking ship.

Witness Scotia Mocatta's exit, and if Ted is correct, J.P. Morgan's has reversed its long-standing position of being massively short silver, to going long.

The "normal" Gold/Silver Ratio is set to fundamentally change.

Silver's price ratio to gold briefly hit 15:1 in 1980 and set a new record in March 2020 with a spike to about 125:1. But its "normal" range oscillates between 40 and 80.

Like a stone tossed into a quiet pool, the rings of effect will spread out in ever-widening circles, when (not if) this comes to pass.

As Willem Middelkoop, Author of The Big Reset says, "If silver breaks, then the gold manipulation might break as well, and then you will have a real crisis within the monetary system, because then the dollar system is at risk... This is what can happen, and I believe will happen to silver...

There are structural changes for silver in the supply/demand metric, projected growth of new use cases, degradation of a decades-long pattern of unrestrained "paper silver" futures and mining share selling – not to mention changing investment demand ratios compared to industrial use.

Therefore, it's probable that – just like the gold-to-platinum, and platinum-to-palladium ratios – silver is set to massively outperform gold.

The First Stage: Just moving the ratio into the lower range of 40:1 gives us all-time nominal highs and vast outperformance for silver.

The Second Stage: Turning the gold/silver ratio on its head. Another underappreciated factor is that Bitcoin's meteoric rise, if sustained, could blunt global gold demand.

Let's say that silver, as factored above, goes through the roof and briefly hits $500 the ounce while gold hits $10,000. Doing the math gives us a 20:1 ratio.

Then if silver recedes to $250 you would have a "normal" 40:1 ratio. Under this scenario, primary silver producers would be "digging up money" in exchange for fiat!

Meanwhile, it's not a good idea to "challenge" the COMEX.

In The Art of War, Sun Tzu cautioned against attacking an opponent head on. He also said you should set the field of battle so that you had already won before the conflict began.

This is exactly what the denizens at the "CRIMEX" do, and why they continually defeat all comers.

They can:

Change the rules (-see The Hunt Bros. 1980)

Alter margin limits and sell unlimited paper silver.

Enforce a trading rule of "offset positions only."

"Settle" silver obligations with fiat.

A (much) better way to "un-game" the silver system.

Uber-trader "Plunger" writing on Rambus1 com, comments: So why the strength in silver? I think it’s because the bullion bank silver cartel is in the process of unraveling and its ability to maintain its concentrated short position is entering into its last days...despite the army of silver detractors out there, the charts signal to me that silver is on the verge of a breakout..."

The WallStreetBets-Robinhood-GameStop fiasco poked a hole in the vaunted Masters of the Universe's game plan.

The losers are learning the old winner's tactics and bringing new tools to bear.

Don't try to win by holding "faux silver" positions like the ETF SLV.

Don't buy silver from trading houses that charge you for an empty vault while they write derivatives and lease out what they do have.

Instead…

Attack their flanks and underbelly by purchasing .999 fine physical silver.

Add what you can on a regular basis - what happened a few weekends ago was just a preview.

This will keep the pressure on the paper pushers as the ongoing effect of declining silver production through lower grade and a dearth of big discoveries takes silver stores into their fifth consecutive year of decline... just like what happened to palladium.

News broke this week that BlackRock, the world's largest asset manager, sold a third of its GLD shares in late 2020 and put a big chunk of the proceeds into the silver ETF, SLV.

It sure looks like the dominoes holding up the old way of doing things are starting to fall. If even BlackRock is now "going for the silver" shouldn't you?


To receive free commentary and analysis on the gold and silver markets, click here to be added to the Money Metals news service.

Author

David Smith

David Smith

Money Metals Exchange

More from David Smith
Share:

Markets move fast. We move first.

Orange Juice Newsletter brings you expert driven insights - not headlines. Every day on your inbox.

By subscribing you agree to our Terms and conditions.

Editor's Picks

EUR/USD moves sideways below 1.1800 on Christmas Eve

EUR/USD struggles to find direction and trades in a narrow channel below 1.1800 after posting gains for two consecutive days. Bond and stock markets in the US will open at the usual time and close early on Christmas Eve, allowing the trading action to remain subdued. 

GBP/USD keeps range around 1.3500 amid quiet markets

GBP/USD keeps its range trade intact at around 1.3500 on Wednesday. The Pound Sterling holds the upper hand over the US Dollar amid pre-Christmas light trading as traders move to the sidelines heading into the holiday season. 

Gold retreats from record highs, trades below $4,500

Gold retreats after setting a new record-high above $4,520 earlier in the day and trades in a tight range below $4,500 as trading volumes thin out ahead of the Christmas break. The US Dollar selling bias remains unabated on the back of dovish Fed expectations, which continues to act as a tailwind for the bullion amid persistent geopolitical risks.

Bitcoin slips below $87,000 as ETF outflows intensify, whale participation declines

Bitcoin price continues to trade around $86,770 on Wednesday, after failing to break above the $90,000 resistance. US-listed spot ETFs record an outflow of $188.64 million on Tuesday, marking the fourth consecutive day of withdrawals.

Economic outlook 2026-2027 in advanced countries: Solidity test

After a year marked by global economic resilience and ending on a note of optimism, 2026 looks promising and could be a year of solid economic performance. In our baseline scenario, we expect most of the supportive factors at work in 2025 to continue to play a role in 2026.

Avalanche struggles near $12 as Grayscale files updated form for ETF

Avalanche trades close to $12 by press time on Wednesday, extending the nearly 2% drop from the previous day. Grayscale filed an updated form to convert its Avalanche-focused Trust into an ETF with the US Securities and Exchange Commission.