|

Nvidia's rivals are falling with it now and that's the real warning sign

Nvidia's rivals are falling with it now and that's the real warning sign

Advanced Micro Devices and Broadcom rallied when Jensen Huang left Nvidia, then fell alongside it. Their customers are the same data centre builders that lean on $230 billion of Nvidia guarantees, and no other chipmaker is big enough to replace that backing.


For five trading days, the easiest trade in chip stocks was to own Advanced Micro Devices (AMD) and sell the Jensen Huang-founded Nvidia (NVDA). AMD rose 44.7% in the five sessions to November 12, helped first by record results and then by bets that it would inherit Nvidia's customers. Nvidia fell 8.5% over the same period, and Huang resigned as chief executive on the last day. That 53.2-point gap was the widest in AMD's favour since Nvidia listed in 1999, and since then AMD has fallen faster than the company it was supposed to be replacing.

That reversal says more about the artificial intelligence (AI) trade than Nvidia's own slide does. Nvidia's competitors sell to the same data centre builders that Nvidia has been backing with its own money and credit. If that backing shrinks under new management, orders would likely shrink for every chipmaker, and none of the others is large enough to take over as the backer.

The swap trade lasted a week

The swap made sense on paper. AMD had just reported record quarterly revenue of $13.4 billion, with sales to data centres up about 97% from a year earlier, and a crisis at its largest competitor looked like an opening. Broadcom (AVGO) gained on the same reasoning, and for a few days traders treated Nvidia's trouble as something that belonged to Nvidia alone.

By the next session, that view had started to crack. AMD lost 8.75% on November 13 and another 5.6% on Monday, when Nvidia fell 4.1%. Micron (MU) and TSMC (TSM), which supply Nvidia more than they compete with it, dropped 7.6% and 6.3% on Monday, and the Philadelphia Semiconductor Index, the main gauge of US-listed chip stocks, lost 5.3%.

With AMD on track for a third straight fall on Tuesday, it has handed back close to half of that five-day gain. The widest gap AMD has opened over Nvidia in 27 years was set on a Thursday and started closing on the Friday.

Nvidia sells the chips and lends the money

The explanation starts with how AI data centres get paid for. Many of the companies building them are specialist cloud firms that rent out computing power and have weak credit, so landlords and banks have wanted a bigger name standing behind the leases and loans. Nvidia has been that name. Reuters puts its financial guarantees, promises to cover a customer's payments if the customer can't, at $230 billion, including up to $105 billion behind the Ohio data centre that OpenAI plans to lease.

With those guarantees in place, the builders could borrow, and the buildings they borrowed for were filled with chips, most of them Nvidia's, though AMD and Broadcom sell to the same builders. That makes Nvidia's credit a source of orders for its competitors as well as for itself. Morgan Stanley (MS) estimates the specialist cloud firms bring in close to a quarter of Nvidia's revenue, and one of the biggest, CoreWeave (CRWV), reported results that helped lift AMD on November 11.

From there, the worry is about who is now in charge of the guarantees. Interim Chief Executive Colette Kress was Nvidia's finance chief for 13 years, and the startups that depend on the backing reportedly expect her to offer less of it. The Information has reported that chip executives doubt AMD or Broadcom could take on guarantees of that size if Nvidia pulls back. The arithmetic is on their side, because the OpenAI guarantee alone is nearly eight times AMD's record quarter of revenue.



The new export rule doesn't check whose chip it is

On top of the financing worry, two other pressures apply to every chipmaker equally. The first came from Washington on Monday, when the Commerce Department issued a rule requiring a US licence for advanced AI chips sent to data centres in Singapore, Malaysia, Thailand, Indonesia and Brazil. The same rule covers any data centre, anywhere, that rents large amounts of computing power to companies based in China.

In that light, it would be easy to file the rule as one more Nvidia problem, since it followed scrutiny of chip exports that began with the allegations around Nvidia. The rule is written around the product, though, so an AMD processor bound for Kuala Lumpur now needs the same licence as an Nvidia one.

The second pressure is a share sale by Anthropic, the company behind the Claude AI models, which is due to list on Nasdaq by Friday. Its initial public offering (IPO), a first sale of shares to the public, could raise up to $64.4 billion, and fund managers who want those shares may have to sell other technology holdings to pay for them. Seven of Anthropic's chip and cloud suppliers have also agreed to buy $26 billion of its stock alongside the offering, with Nvidia putting in $10 billion, AMD $2.5 billion, and Broadcom and Micron $1 billion each. Nvidia's competitors, in other words, have joined it in funding a customer so that the customer can keep buying chips.



AMD still holds about half its gain

The strongest objection is that three bad days after a 45% run are ordinary profit-taking, the selling that locks in a gain. Traders who bought AMD as a bet against Nvidia had every reason to cash out before Nvidia's results, and AMD has kept about half of that five-day gain even after the pullback.

Behind the share price, AMD's business has shown no sign of slowing either. The company has told investors to expect about $17 billion of revenue for the current quarter and expects sales to grow by more than 80% in 2027, while TSMC's October revenue was up 59.7% from a year earlier. AMD has also reportedly started backing some of it itself, stepping in after Nvidia declined to take on a lease for CoreWeave in Georgia.

Still, the objection holds only if Nvidia's financing continues as before, and one lease in Georgia is a long way from $230 billion in guarantees. AMD's shares trade at 202 times the past year's earnings, a price that assumes the company keeps every customer it has and adds Nvidia's.

What Kress does with the guarantees decides it

Nvidia reports its third-quarter results on Tuesday, after regular trading, and analysts expect revenue of about $109 billion, close to double the figure from a year earlier. Revenue is the part of the report with the fewest doubts attached, given that Nvidia has beaten forecasts for six straight quarters.

Beyond the revenue line, what matters for the rest of the sector is what Kress says about the guarantees. If she keeps the existing commitments and stays open to new ones, the data centre builders can still borrow, and AMD and Broadcom would likely go back to trading on their own sales. In that case, the past three sessions would look like profit-taking after all.

If she signals a pause instead, the builders would have to find lenders willing to take their credit without Nvidia behind it. JPMorgan (JPM) credit analyst Erica Spear said she doesn't expect existing commitments to change, but new deals could take longer or cost more. Lenders were asking close to 15% a year to hold CoreWeave's bonds in the week to November 13, which gives a sense of what unbacked money costs. Fewer buildings would mean fewer chips from every supplier, and the stocks that rose on Nvidia's trouble would have the most to give back.

For now, the lean is that the competitors stay tied to Nvidia, because the lending question will outlast one earnings call and the board has yet to name a permanent chief executive. That view breaks if Nvidia confirms the guarantees in full and AMD and Broadcom go back to rising on days when Nvidia falls. The swap trade needs Nvidia to be weak enough to lose customers and strong enough to keep lending to them, and it hasn't managed both on the same day since November 12.

Author

Joshua Gibson

Joshua joins the FXStreet team as an Economics and Finance double major from Vancouver Island University with twelve years' experience as an independent trader focusing on technical analysis.

More from Joshua Gibson
Share:

Editor's Picks

AUD/USD remains depressed below 0.6750 after RBA minutes

AUD/USD treads water below 0.6750 in Asia on Tuesday, struggling near ten-month lows. The pair fails to find any inspiration from RBA Governor Bullock’s hawkish remarks. Moreover, Minutes from the November RBA meeting also had little impact on the Australian Dollar amid a bullish US Dollar undertone, bolstered by firming Fed hike bets and geopolitical uncertainties.

USD/JPY holds steady around 156.50 as 'Yentervention' risks loom

USD/JPY is consolidating around mid-156.00s in the Asian session on Tuesday as traders stay on high alert amid speculation that authorities will step in to support the Japanese Yen. Meanwhile, the US Dollar holds its recent gains at a 19-month high, amid firming Fed rate-hike bets and geopolitical uncertainty. This, along with the wide US-Japan rate differential, acts as a tailwind for the pair.



Gold picks up pace; struggles to leave behind $3,850

Gold regains some composure and attempts to surpass the $3,850 mark per troy ounce on Tuesday. Despite the bullish attempt, the precious metal remains subdued amid the continuation of the upside momentum in the US Dollar, speculation of further Fed tightening and a modest bounce in US Treasury yields across the curve.

Ripple bulls struggle as Binance whale withdrawals surge

XRP trades marginally above $0.95 as bulls push to gain ground, but upside remains strongly capped. XRP whales withdrew $21 million from Binance on Monday, extending broader $127 million outflows since November 10.

Make or break tonight: Nvidia reports Q3 earnings
The Nasdaq lost 2.5% yesterday following an interim final rule by the US Commerce Department on US export restrictions on AI chips (to China). The rule targets a loophole where Chinese firms rent computing power from data centers in unrestricted countries. Data center operators in Singapore, Malaysia, Thailand, Indonesia and Brazil must now request a US license to buy advanced AI chips.
Gold isn't being sold for thew reason most people think
Gold (XAU/USD) remains under heavy selling pressure on Monday, hitting its lowest level in 13 months. The precious metal is struggling to recover despite escalating geopolitical tensions in the Middle East, a backdrop that would normally encourage investors to seek protection in safe-haven assets. However, the main driver behind Gold's decline is not the geopolitical uncertainty itself.