|

Why CLARITY Act's failure is beneficial for crypto — Bitwise

  • Bitwise's Matt Hougan said Bitcoin gained 8% and Ethereum 7%, while NEAR, Uniswap and Avalanche posted larger gains after the Senate failed to pass the CLARITY Act.
  • He highlighted that CLARITY's failure gives exchanges more flexibility to offer rewards on stablecoin balances under the GENIUS Act.
  • Hougan added that the legislative setback opened the door for the SEC to back tokenization platforms and revenue-generating tokens under new rules.​
Why CLARITY Act's failure is beneficial for crypto — Bitwise

Bitwise CIO Matt Hougan stated Wednesday that the crypto market has rallied since the US Senate failed to advance the CLARITY Act, arguing that the legislation’s collapse allowed regulators to move faster on industry rules.

Crypto gains momentum despite legislative setback

Hougan noted that Bitcoin (BTC) has gained 8% and Ethereum (ETH) 7% since the vote, while several altcoins posted larger gains. NEAR rose 104%, Uniswap (UNI) gained 49% and Avalanche (AVAX) advanced 43%.

Although the crypto industry backed the legislation for the regulatory certainty it promised, Hougan stated that the final negotiations required compromises that could have restricted parts of the sector.

Stablecoins were among the biggest areas affected by the legislation’s failure. One key dispute during negotiations involved whether exchanges could pass stablecoin-related interest or rewards to customers. Banks opposed provisions that would have allowed platforms to offer such benefits.

The final version of the CLARITY Act would have prohibited platforms from paying stablecoin interest or yield to customers “in any form,” with penalties of up to $5 million per violation.

Although the bill failed, the Genius Act remains in effect. The law prohibits stablecoin issuers from paying interest but does not impose the same restriction on exchanges.

“The great irony for banks is that their refusal to compromise will likely end up helping every stablecoin take market share from the traditional system,” Hougan wrote.

SEC actions open new opportunities for crypto

Tokenization has also benefited from developments after the Senate vote. Two days after the CLARITY Act failed, the SEC issued an order allowing tokenized US stocks to trade through permissioned automated market makers and liquidity pools. The order exempts participating venues from registering as exchanges and liquidity providers from registering as dealers.

The measure is limited to five years, covers listed US stocks and includes volume restrictions, but Hougan highlighted that the approach lets the industry experiment rather than wait years for regulatory studies.

Hougan identified Securitize as a major beneficiary. The company provides tokenization infrastructure for funds from BlackRock, Apollo and KKR and serves as the transfer agent for BlackRock’s BUIDL fund.

The report also pointed to tokens that use protocol revenue for buybacks, including NEAR and Uniswap.

"One reason for their success is that, oddly, revenue-generating tokens have clearer rules without Clarity than they would have had with it," Hougan added.

Under the proposed CLARITY framework, uncertainty remained over whether buybacks could affect a token’s regulatory classification. After the bill failed, the SEC wrote in an FAQ that once a network is functional, announcing a buyback program does not make its token a security.

Hougan acknowledged that the main risk is regulators taking a different approach in the future.

However, he argued that continued blockchain adoption by major financial institutions could make a significant regulatory reversal more difficult.

Author

Michael Ebiekutan

With a deep passion for web3 technology, he's collaborated with industry-leading brands like Mara, ITAK, and FXStreet in delivering groundbreaking reports on web3's transformative potential across diverse sectors. In addition to

More from Michael Ebiekutan
Share:

Editor's Picks

Ripple accelerates decline below $1.00 amid fading retail participation

Ripple (XRP) ticks down on Monday, trading at $0.95 as sellers remain largely in control. Bulls' attempts to regain control have increasingly failed in recent weeks, aligning with the broader crypto market.

Crypto Today: Bitcoin, Ethereum, XRP face increasing selling pressure, ETF outflows

Bitcoin trades lower below $65,000 on Monday, as selling pressure expands in the broader cryptocurrency market, accentuated by growing risk-off sentiment. Ethereum paints a similar grim picture, with the price sliding near $1,800 while Ripple remains below $0.95.

Pi Network remains under pressure near record lows as bears dominate

Pi Network remains under pressure on Monday after setting a fresh all-time low near $0.0600 on Saturday. Derivatives positioning points to persistent bearish sentiment among PI traders.

Bitcoin Price Forecast: ETF outflows hit $1.07 billion as BTC struggles to recover from oversold levels

Bitcoin (BTC) struggles to regain ground, trading below $65,200 on Monday after extending its decline to a low of $62,006 last week, levels not seen since mid-July.

Bitcoin: BTC drops below $68,000 as oversold signal fails to stop sellers
Bitcoin (BTC) extends its correction, falling more than 8% and hitting an intraday low of $67,568 on Friday. Despite oversold technical signals, selling pressure continues to intensify, with persistent Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs) outflows, leveraged liquidations and weakening risk appetite weighing on the Crypto King outlook.