Tough, currency manipulation penalties contained within the draft of the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) may sound the death knell of the trade pacts approval by the Obama Administration. In recent days, the US administration has made it clear that any agreement that includes language concerning penalties for currency manipulation would be vetoed immediately.

The main argument for the exclusion of any form of penalty or provision for currency manipulators stems from the view that it would interfere with the Federal Reserve’s ability to implement monetary policy. The sticking point seems to be that the administration views the ability to engineer a currency depreciation or devaluation as being a power that should be reserved for states dealing with economic downturns.

However, many within congress support the penalty provisions and see them as the way forward to a level playing field for Pacific trade. The ranking member of the House Committee on Trade, Representative Levin of Michigan, is a significant proponent of stronger currency protections. Subsequently, Levin has strongly suggested that any move to oppose currency manipulation provisions is simply a false argument.

Although there is scant data on the included provisions within the TPP, it seems to be intellectually dishonest to suggest that introducing currency manipulation provisions would impede monetary policy implementation. The agreed definition of “Currency Manipulator” status is likely to have a high burden of proof. Subsequently it could be argued that the majority of loose monetary policy that a central bank may undertake would be unlikely to be caught within that net.

The real reason that the currency provisions are an essential component of the trade agreement is simple. It stops the race to the bottom. In recent years, countries under pressure have realised that it is much easier to depreciate their currencies to secure their export markets then it is to invest in productivity gains to obtain a competitive advantage.

The net effect of a trade agreement, without provisions dealing with currency manipulation, is one of a toothless tiger with no bite. At the first hint of increased competition within critical domestic industries, some participants will seek a currency depreciation to alter the demand and competitiveness of their exports.

Any review of potential currency manipulation would likely be handled by the World Trade Organisation (WTO) in a manner similar to current provisions. So it is difficult to reconcile how enshrining these provisions within the key trade agreement is likely to impede domestic monetary policy. However, the argument has been made that, as there are currently no case precedents for WTO decisions to rely upon, that any outcome of a complaint would be unpredictable. Surely this aspect is an argument in favour of a tighter framework for dealing with currency manipulators, rather than removing the provisions completely?

Ultimately, the Obama administration is hell-bent on protecting the perceived sovereignty of the Federal Reserve over monetary policy. Subsequently, any move to include the penalty provisions could be a poison pill within negotiations. However, the alternative is unthinkable…an agreement without any form of enforceability that is open to abuse.

Risk Warning: Any form of trading or investment carries a high level of risk to your capital and you should only trade with money you can afford to lose. The information and strategies contained herein may not be suitable for all investors, so please ensure that you fully understand the risks involved and you are advised to seek independent advice from a registered financial advisor. The advice on this website is general in nature and does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. You should consider whether the advice is suitable for you and your personal circumstances. The information in this article is not intended for residents of New Zealand and use by any person in any country or jurisdiction where such distribution or use would be contrary to local law or regulation. Knight Review is not a registered financial advisor and in no way intends to provide specific advice to you in any form whatsoever and provide no financial products or services for sale. As always, please take the time to consult with a registered financial advisor in your jurisdiction for a consideration of your specific circumstances.

Recommended Content


Recommended Content

Editors’ Picks

USD/JPY pops and drops on BoJ's expected hold

USD/JPY pops and drops on BoJ's expected hold

USD/JPY  reverses a knee-jerk spike to 142.80 and returns to the red below 142.50 after the Bank of Japan announced on Friday that it maintained the short-term rate target in the range of 0.15%-0.25%. The decision aligned with the market expectations. Governor Ueda's presser eyed. 

USD/JPY News
AUD/USD bears attack 0.6800 amid PBOC's status-quo, cautious mood

AUD/USD bears attack 0.6800 amid PBOC's status-quo, cautious mood

AUD/USD attacks 0.6800 in Friday's Asian trading, extending its gradual retreat after the PBOC unexpectedly left mortgage lending rates unchanged in September. A cautious market mood also adds to the weight on the Aussie. Fedspeak eyed. 

AUD/USD News
Gold consolidates near record high, bullish potential seems intact

Gold consolidates near record high, bullish potential seems intact

Gold price regained positive traction on Thursday and rallied back closer to the all-time peak touched the previous day in reaction to the Federal Reserve's decision to start the policy easing cycle with an oversized rate cut.

Gold News
Ethereum rallies over 6% following decision to split Pectra upgrade into two phases

Ethereum rallies over 6% following decision to split Pectra upgrade into two phases

In its Consensus Layer Call on Thursday, Ethereum developers decided to split the upcoming Pectra upgrade into two batches. The decision follows concerns about potential risks in shipping the previously approved series of Ethereum improvement proposals.

Read more
Bank of Japan set to keep rates on hold after July’s hike shocked markets

Bank of Japan set to keep rates on hold after July’s hike shocked markets

The Bank of Japan is expected to keep its short-term interest rate target between 0.15% and 0.25% on Friday, following the conclusion of its two-day monetary policy review. The decision is set to be announced during the early Asian session. 

Read more
Moneta Markets review 2024: All you need to know

Moneta Markets review 2024: All you need to know

VERIFIED In this review, the FXStreet team provides an independent and thorough analysis based on direct testing and real experiences with Moneta Markets – an excellent broker for novice to intermediate forex traders who want to broaden their knowledge base.

Read More

Majors

Cryptocurrencies

Signatures