Other opinions on the same debate:
• John Forman: Retail Forex Trading is a Negative Sum Game
• Boris Schlossberg: FX market is a zero sum game?

Have you ever played dice with a friend? Betting a fixed amount of money each turn, you win if the number on the top face of the die is one, two or three, your friend wins in all the three other cases. At any single point in time, the sum of all the profits and losses amount up to exactly zero. This is an example of a very simple zero sum game.

A more precise definition is that a zero sum game is a [mathematical representation of a] situation in which a participant's gain (or loss) of utility is exactly balanced by the losses (or gains) of the utility of the other participant(s).

On a first observation, the combination of the example and the more formal definition leads to the conclusion that the utility is represented by the amount you win or lose. This is the first misconception. In many cases it is convenient to assume that this equality holds (like in the game of dice) but that is not generally the case.

Think of a large multinational institution that has exposure in many different countries, hence exposed to fluctuations in the respective currency rates. For proper financial planning this institution hedges a part of its exposure. The counter party might be a normal retail trader (although quite unlikely) with a different goal in mind. The utility of these two counterparties could not be more different: the institution 'does not mind' losing (regarding its utility) while the retail trader wants to profit from this single trade. In this scenario, the utilities of the two parties are not offset by each other because if the hedge is carried out perfectly, the institution is 'flat' while the retail trader wins.

Regarding utility, all trading activity is by definition a positive sum game: when two parties agree to make a trade, each of the parties considers the good it is receiving as more valuable than the good it is delivering.

For the further discussion, let's assume that utility is represented by the financial loss/profit. A short term trader can sell his position to any another participant, regardless of the investment horizon of the counterparty. Contrary to playing dice, there is no 'round end' when one sums up profits and losses. This means that the short term trader as well as the long term trader (as well as the broker/market maker) can make a profit on the position. The markets are an infinite (and not finite) multiplayer game.

Finally, it does not make sense to view the FX market isolated from the 'rest' of the economy. The currency market as a whole can appreciate or depreciate relative to other measures of value (commodities, resources, …), i.e. both EUR and USD can appreciate with regard to grain. Hence, the trader long EUR and the trader long USD both make an objective profit (with regard to grain).

Trading forex is a positive sum game because market participants trade with different subjective measures of 'value' called utility and may have different time horizons, in such a way that both parties can realize a profit. This, however, does not imply, that the majority of traders lose money in the markets; this is due to other reasons and worth another article.

Education feed Join Telegram

Editors’ Picks

EUR/USD steadies near 1.0550, looks to post modest weekly gains

EUR/USD steadies near 1.0550, looks to post modest weekly gains

EUR/USD has lost its bullish momentum after having climbed above 1.0570 with the initial reaction to the US data in the American session and retreated toward the mid-1.0500s. On a weekly basis, the pair remains on track to close in positive territory. 

EUR/USD News

GBP/USD struggles to hold above 1.2300

GBP/USD struggles to hold above 1.2300

GBP/USD has edged lower following a jump above 1.2300 in the early American session on Friday. The market mood remains upbeat ahead of the weekend with Wall Street's main indexes posting strong daily gains on upbeat US data. 

GBP/USD News

USD/JPY: Loss of upside momentum looks imminent

USD/JPY: Loss of upside momentum looks imminent

The USD/JPY pair is displaying wild moves after the release of Japan’s Inflation. The asset is facing barricades around the round-level resistance of 135.00. On a broader note, the major has witnessed a steep fall after failing to sustain above the critical hurdle of 136.00.

USD/JPY News

Editors’ Picks

EUR/USD steadies near 1.0550, looks to post modest weekly gains

EUR/USD steadies near 1.0550, looks to post modest weekly gains

EUR/USD has lost its bullish momentum after having climbed above 1.0570 with the initial reaction to the US data in the American session and retreated toward the mid-1.0500s. On a weekly basis, the pair remains on track to close in positive territory. 

EUR/USD News

GBP/USD struggles to hold above 1.2300

GBP/USD struggles to hold above 1.2300

GBP/USD has edged lower following a jump above 1.2300 in the early American session on Friday. The market mood remains upbeat ahead of the weekend with Wall Street's main indexes posting strong daily gains on upbeat US data. 

GBP/USD News

Gold stays below $1,830 as US yields edge higher

Gold stays below $1,830 as US yields edge higher

Gold continues to fluctuate below $1,830 on Friday and looks to close the second straight week in negative territory. Fueled by the risk-positive market environment, the benchmark 10-year US Treasury bond yield is up more than 1% on the day, limiting XAU/USD's upside.

Gold News

Why Cardano could surprise over the weekend

Why Cardano could surprise over the weekend

ADA  set to close out the week with a gain on the workday trading week and over the weekend? Central banks signaled that the rate hike cycle is ending, meaning less stress and tight conditions for trading, opening up room for some upside potential with Cardano set to pop above $0.55 and test a significant cap.

Read more

FXStreet Premium users exceed expectations

FXStreet Premium users exceed expectations

Tap into our 20 years Forex trading experience and get ahead of the markets. Maximize our actionable content, be part of our community, and chat with our experts. Join FXStreet Premium today!

BECOME PREMIUM

RECOMMENDED LESSONS

7 Ways to Avoid Forex Scams

The forex industry is recently seeing more and more scams. Here are 7 ways to avoid losing your money in such scams: Forex scams are becoming frequent. Michael Greenberg reports on luxurious expenses, including a submarine bought from the money taken from forex traders. Here’s another report of a forex fraud. So, how can we avoid falling in such forex scams?

What Are the 10 Fatal Mistakes Traders Make

Trading is exciting. Trading is hard. Trading is extremely hard. Some say that it takes more than 10,000 hours to master. Others believe that trading is the way to quick riches. They might be both wrong. What is important to know that no matter how experienced you are, mistakes will be part of the trading process.

Strategy

Money Management

Psychology