The Porcupine Flips

In The Porcupine Flips, Eurointelligence provides amusing as well as accurate statements about the ECB's inflation models. The same applies to the US, even more so. 

If anyone wonders why the pandemic models have been hopelessly wrong, just take a look at inflation models. Pandemic models are actually not too bad by comparison. Sure, they are wrong most of the time, but they are wrong in the normal sense in which models are wrong. They are sometimes too pessimistic, sometimes too optimistic.

Macroeconomic inflation models have the unique distinction of being wrong and biased. They perform worse than all of the following: a random number generator, a soothsayer with big ball, and a monkey with a dartboard. I am not suggesting that central banks should replace staff economists with monkeys. But if they did, the first thing we would note is a measurable reduction in forecasting bias. Wrong and unbiased is better than wrong and biased.

Our graph above is a stylised version of what has happened in the euro area, and what I expect to happen. The left side is nicknamed the porcupine chart, with the dotted lines representing the forecasts at various times, the blue line the rate of inflation, and the red line the inflation target. Note that the forecasts always erred in the same direction. This is because the inflation models are hardwired to predict inflation to revert to ECB's 2% target. It is an example of policy bias. If you predicted some other number, you would indirectly acknowledge that your policy is wrong.

Apart from policy bias, there is another important reason why central bank forecasting models perform so poorly. The models are not built for an inherently unstable environment, like our global economy since the financial crisis. The models have no way of dealing with financial shocks, pandemics and global supply chain shocks with persistent effects. Shocks do exist in those models, but their long-term net effect is zero. The 1970s do not exist in those models. Stagflation is impossible. The world of those models is a parallel universe.

If weather models performed similarly poorly, they would have been discarded a long time ago. But economists and central banks have invested so much into these models that the action of discarding them would imply a loss of face. Central banks cling to a strange definition of credibility. They are not the people who say: we tried it. It did not work. We are now going to try something else. Like a gambler facing ruin, they double down.

The intellectually lazy central banker relies on models that explain a world of unknown unknowns with known knowns.

That is one of the best columns Wolfgang Münchau has ever written, if not the best. 

Readers know I have been hounding the Fed and its ridiculous models for years. 

Fed models 

  • Phillips Curve.

  • Inflation Expectations. 

  • Consumer Spending Expectations.

The Fed models all of those things and more. It places great weight on models that are both  logically and proven nonsense.

In search of the Phillips Curve

Chart

Regarding point 1, Yet Another Fed Study Concludes Phillips Curve is Nonsense. 

Previously I noted that a Fed Study Shows Phillips Curve Is Useless. Yet, economists keep trying.

Both studies were done by Fed staffers. 

Yet, Fed Chairs Janet Yellen and Jerome Powell did not believe the Fed's own study. 

in March of 2017, Janet Yellen commented the "Phillips Curve is Alive“.

Fed presidents continue to believe their own academic training on the model, proven not to work in practice.

Mercy Me! Inflation expectations are no longer well-anchored

Chart

For most of eight years reported inflation was under 2% and often under 1%, and briefly negative. Yet, the look ahead median point prediction was never below 2.9%.

If expectations mattered, why did the CPI and PCE stay below 2% so long? 

Chart

Expectations fantasy

  • For most of 8 consecutive years, year-over-year CPI and PCE was under 2%.

  • In that same time frame, the Median 3-year estimate and the median point projections was seldom below 3%.

  • If inflation expectations mattered, that chart would be impossible.

  • Alternatively, one might say people believe low inflation is transitory.

  • Yet, we constantly hear the Fed yapping "Inflation expectations are well anchored".

Elastic vs Inelastic demand

Chart

I highlighted inelastic items.

Perhaps a portion of education is elastic. But a portion of other housing is inelastic as is a portion of communication and other goods.

Recreation is elastic and so is apparel (assuming one does not ruin one's only coat or shoes).

Somewhere between 80% and 90% of household purchases are inelastic.

Yet, the Fed is fully 100% committed to belief in inflation expectations. 

 

This material is based upon information that Sitka Pacific Capital Management considers reliable and endeavors to keep current, Sitka Pacific Capital Management does not assure that this material is accurate, current or complete, and it should not be relied upon as such.

Feed news

Latest Forex Analysis


Latest Forex Analysis

Editors’ Picks

EUR/USD retreats below 1.1300 area as NFP-inspired dollar weakness fades

EUR/USD jumped to a daily high of 1.1333 with the initial market reaction to the disappointing November Nonfarm Payrolls data but quickly returned below 1.1300. Rising US Treasury bond yields seem to be helping the dollar stay resilient against its major rivals. 

EUR/USD News

GBP/USDdrops to 1.3250 area as dollar regains strength

GBP/USD spiked above 1.3300 in the early American session with the initial market reaction to the gloomy US November jobs report. However, the greenback regathered strength on hawkish Fed commentary and forced the pair to turn south.

GBP/USD News

Gold struggles to capitalize on weak NFP data, holds near $1,770

Gold spiked to a daily high near $1,780 with the initial market reaction to the disappointing Nonfarm Payrolls data from the US but seems to be having a difficult time preserving its bullish momentum with the 10-year US T-bond yield staying resilient.

Gold News

The bull and the bear case for BTC

Bitcoin price saw a bullish impulse that faced massive headwinds before it tagged a crucial psychological barrier. Bitcoin is likely to experience massive volatility as the situation resolves over time. 

Read more

Cyber Monday 2021 Discounts!

Glued to your trading screen on Cyber Monday? Upgrade your skills by signing up for FXStreet’s Premium service, offered at a discount of up to 50%. Fellow traders have already taken advantage of Black Friday profits. What about you? 

Subscribe now!

Majors

Cryptocurrencies

Signatures