U.S. Review

Plenty to Shout About

There has been a whole lot of shouting going on over the past few weeks, as fears about the economy and financial markets are clearly rattling a lot of nerves. There are growing concerns that economic policy is heading in the wrong direction and that the economic stimulus package will be ineffective or even counterproductive. We feel these judgments are a bit premature and overreaching. The economy will eventually recover and the stimulus package will, at a minimum, play at least a supporting role. In the short-term, however, there is clearly more pain ahead.

The big news this week was the February employment report, which showed the economy losing 651,000 nonfarm jobs and the unemployment rate jumping 0.5 percentage points to 8.1 percent. Job losses continue to be incredibly broad-based and previously reported drops in December and January are now shown to be much worse than first reported.

Job losses remain extraordinarily broad based. The diffusion index for nonfarm payrolls was just 23.8 in February and averaged just 22.5 over the past three months.

First Quarter GDP Should be Worse than the Previous Quarter

Average weekly hours have remained unchanged at 33.3 hours for the past three months, which indicates employers are reducing employment rather than simply cutting back hours. Layoffs have been extraordinary, however, with nearly two million jobs lost in just the past three months. With employment plummeting and the workweek unchanged, total hours worked plunged at an 8.8 percent annual rate over the past three months.

The plunge in aggregate hours worked suggests real GDP will decline even more during the current quarter than it did during the fourth quarter. The sum of aggregate hours worked and nonfarm productivity is a good proxy for real GDP growth. Nonfarm productivity declined at a 0.4 percent annual rate during the fourth quarter and increased 2.2 percent over the past year. Nonfarm productivity has averaged a 1.7 percent pace over the past three years and this is probably the best figure to use to compute an interim GDP estimate. Using that figure results in a 7.1 percent decline in first quarter real GDP, which is close to our early bottoms up estimate for our March Monthly Economic Outlook.

Most of this week’s other economic reports also point to an incredibly weak first quarter. Construction spending plunged 3.3 percent in January, with particularly large declines in commercial construction and the formerly strong energy and power sector. Pending home sales and unit car and truck sales also declined, with pending home sales falling 7.7 percent in January. Separately, manufacturers’ new vehicle sales to dealers fell by a half million units to a 9.1 million unit annual rate. Factory orders fell 1.9 percent in January, which was slightly less than expected. The previous month’s drop was revised a percentage point lower, however, and the key non-defense capital goods orders series plummeted 5.7 percent. The weakness in orders and shipments suggests that business fixed investment will decline sharply in the first quarter and probably all of this year.

The only good news this week was that first time claims for unemployment insurance fell 28,000 to 639,000. It was the first decline in four weeks and leaves jobless claims at a historically high level. Continuing claims also declined, falling 6,000 to 5,106,000. Weekly first-time jobless claims are extremely volatile and this past week’s drop probably does not mark a turnaround but rather a slowdown in the rate of deterioration in the labor market. We expect the exceptionally weak employment numbers to persist through the middle of this year and then become progressively less bad during the second half of the year.


Global Review

Central Banks Try to Stem the Tide

After a spate of economic indicators came in worse than expected in recent weeks, central banks across the globe scrambled to ratchet down their already dour forecasts to what appears to be the new grim reality of a bad global recession.

After Canadian GDP fell at an annualized rate of 3.4 percent in the Q4, the Bank of Canada (BoC) cut its key lending rate to a record low 0.50 percent at its scheduled meeting the next day. The BoC acknowledged its global economic outlook had deteriorated since last month’s report “with weaker-than-expected activity” around the world. On the other side of the Atlantic, the Bank of England (BoE) made a similar move, cutting its lending rate to 0.50 percent. In addition, the bank announced a £75 billion plan to buy government and private sector bonds, a move that led to a scant 60 bp drop in the U.K. 10-year government bond yield in two days.

Bank of England Taking a Cue from the FOMC

The BoE had been reluctant to cut rates quickly over the last year even as the Federal Reserve was quick to do so. The rationale for not rushing to bring down the lending rate drastically had to do with the BoE’s mandate to keep inflation near two percent, when last fall year-over-year inflation was over five percent. But inflation -- at a year-over-year rate of 3.0 percent in January -- poses less of a threat. With just about every major economy around the world mired in recession, there is less danger of runaway inflation taking hold. In addition to the problem of slowing growth abroad, there were signs this week that domestic demand in the United Kingdom was falling apart as well. The purchasing managers’ indexes for both manufacturing and the service sector remained in contraction territory in February though the survey for the service sector has begun to show tentative signs of recovery. BoE Governor Mervin King wrote to the Chancellor of the Exchequer noting that in “these highly uncertain times, there are merits to stimulating the economy through a variety of different channels.” By means of this correspondence, the BoE governor sought – and received – authorization to print money and buy financial assets. In remarks following the official announcement Chancellor Darling noted that “America has been doing something like this for several months.”

Across the English Channel, the European Central Bank (ECB) moved to cut its rate 50 basis points to 1.50 percent. The ECB has been the “last one in” in the effort by the world’s central banks to cut rates and provide liquidity to a choked credit market. The situation in the Euro-zone has quickly gone from bad to worse. Data released this week showed that the 16-country economy contracted at a 5.8 percent annual rate in the fourth quarter. It is unclear in what sector any recovery will begin in the Euro-zone. There is little hope for a quick turnaround in manufacturing as the manufacturing PMI is at an all time low. Consumer spending in the Euro-zone is likely to remain against the ropes as unemployment is now over eight percent and consumer confidence is also at a record low. With EU rules forbidding the ECB from buying government bonds, it is hard to imagine the ECB fostering a rally in government bonds as the BoE did this week.