U.S. Review
A Whole Month of Halloween
After the month we have had, Halloween should not scare anyone. The financial markets have been exceptionally turbulent and the economic data have been extremely disappointing. Real GDP declined at a 0.3 percent annual rate in the third quarter and it looks like a recession is underway. The current quarter looks like it will be substantially weaker and the pace of layoffs and unemployment rate are both expected to increase.
October marked one of the worst months ever for the financial markets. Through yesterday’s close, the Dow Jones Industrial Average was on pace to be the worst month since and MSCI World index is on pace to have its worst month ever. Short-term funding markets, including the commercial paper and Eurodollar markets, seized up for much of the month and only have recently shown signs of thawing somewhat.
While the economic data have not been anywhere near as apocalyptic as the financial data, they do show considerable weakness. Real GDP declined in the third quarter and consumer confidence and factory output both plummeted in October.
Consumers Are Clearly Rattled
The Consumer Confidence Index plunged 21.8 points in October, falling by its largest magnitude and to its lowest level ever. Consumers’ assessment of both current economic conditions and expectations for future economic conditions both plummeted during the month and nearly four times as many households expect business conditions to worsen during the next six months than expected them to improve. Consumers are also increasingly pessimistic about future employment prospects, with just 7.4 percent expecting more jobs to be created and a whopping 41.5 percent expecting fewer jobs to be created.
Consumers’ pessimism about current and future economic conditions means consumers are unlikely to ramp up spending anytime soon. September’s numbers were downright awful, with nominal outlays falling 0.3 percent and inflation-adjusted spending falling 0.4 percent. October’s decline marks the third drop in the past four months and puts real consumer spending down at a 3.1 percent annual rate over the past three months. The latest consumer confidence figures show that buying plans plunged in October, which means spending likely dropped again that month.
Continued weakness in consumer spending is bad news for the overall economic outlook. Real GDP declined at a 0.3 percent annual rate during the third quarter and our latest forecast has real GDP declining at around a 3 percent annual rate during the current quarter. Not only will the current quarter be considerably weaker than the prior one but the weakness also appears to be far more broad based, including not only weakness in consumer outlays but also cutbacks in business fixed investment, exports and state and local government spending.
Along with the weaker consumer confidence data, most of the other early data for October show that economic weakness has intensified. First-time claims for unemployment have continued to inch up to the high 400,000 range. The weekly numbers have been disrupted by weather-related distortions and the extension of unemployment claims. There is no disputing the recent trend, however, which has been solidly and consistently upward. Claims remain at a level consistent with the onset of past recessions and layoff announcements have increased in recent weeks.
The only good news reported in recent weeks has been on the inflation front. The personal consumption deflator rose just 0.1 percent in September and was unchanged in August. Gasoline prices have plummeted in recent weeks, which should lead to even tamer readings on inflation in October and November.
Global Review
Lifelines Thrown to Developing Countries
In our weekly report last Friday we discussed the extraordinary volatility in emerging market currencies that has arisen due to increasing fears of a global recession and a mad scramble for dollar liquidity. This week, steps taken by the International Monetary Fund and the Federal Reserve stopped the run on most emerging market currencies, at least for now.
First, the IMF announced this week that it would lend $16.5 billion to Ukraine and $15.7 billion to Hungary. (Additional loans from the World Bank and the European Union bring the overall size of Hungary’s package to $25 billion). The IMF’s actions this week follow its $2.1 billion loan to Iceland last week.
The IMF went even further this week by announcing a new program dubbed the Short-Term
Liquidity Facility (SLF). Loans extended to Hungary, Iceland and Ukraine will follow “traditional” IMF guidelines. In return for the loans, the respective governments will take steps (e.g., tighter monetary and fiscal policies) to reduce imbalances (e.g., inflation and excessive current account deficits) in their economies that usually result in short-term economic pain. However, there are many developing countries with sound macroeconomic fundamentals that have seen their currencies hammered during the current liquidity crunch. The SLF will allow those countries to borrow from the IMF on a short-term basis to address liquidity issues without making unnecessary policy adjustments.
In support of the IMF, the Federal Reserve announced this week the establishment of $30 billion swap lines to Brazil, Korea, Mexico and Singapore that are authorized until April 30, 2009. The swap lines allow central banks in those countries to borrow dollars from the Fed to help meet acute short-term dollar funding needs in those countries. Following the announcement, the Korean won, which has been battered over the past few weeks, strengthened more than 15 percent against the greenback (see top chart). The Brazilian real (middle chart) and the Mexican peso (bottom chart) also clawed back some lost ground this week.
The steps taken this week by the IMF and the Fed are yet another indication, if any more are needed, that policymakers understand the dire implications for the global economy if the global credit crunch continues. The extraordinary programs announced by governments in many countries over the past few weeks should eventually ease strains in credit markets. Even Japanese policymakers got into the act this week when the Bank of Japan announced a 20 basis point reduction in its main policy rate. (The BoJ cut its target for the overnight interbank rate from 0.50 percent to 0.30 percent.)
Indeed, financial market tensions appear to be easing somewhat. The 3-month U.S. dollar LIBOR rate, which spiked up to 4.82 percent on October 10 when credit market were completely frozen, ended this week at 3.03 percent. Although LIBOR rates, which serve as important benchmarks for other short-term interest rates, remain elevated relative to where they “should” be, are moving in the right direction.







