U.S. Review
The Only Thing We Have To Fear...Fear has taken hold of the financial markets and shaken any semblance of common sense investors had left. Share prices sold off sharply this past week, first on news that General Motors would take a stupendous $39 billion loss in the third quarter and then later on the announcement of another round of write-downs related to the subprime mortgage market meltdown. To make matters worse, oil prices flirted with the psychologically important $100 a barrel level throughout most of the week and earnings from tech bell weather Cisco Corporation came in short of expectations. In addition, chain store sales came in below expectations for October.
Given all of this negative news there is little wonder that investors did not take too kindly to Fed Chairman Ben Bernanke's testimony to the Joint Economic Committee Thursday morning. The stock market initially sold off as investors interpreted Bernanke's testimony to mean that the Fed was finished cutting interest rates. Share prices recovered later in the day, however, as investors seem to have come to
… Is Rising Oil Prices, Subprime Mortgages, And The Dollar
the conclusion that there was very little new information in Bernanke's testimony. The notion that the Fed sees risks both to economic growth and inflation should come as no surprise. Inflation will almost certainly accelerate in coming months as the weaker dollar boosts the price of imports and higher oil prices filter through the economy. Economic growth will also likely slow during the current quarter, but only after third quarter growth is revised even higher. This week's stronger wholesale sales and inventory data along with this morning’s trade data, suggest that third quarter growth may be a full percentage point higher, nearly five percent.
Our most recent forecast was released on Wednesday and we still do not see a recession lurking around the corner. Real GDP growth in the current quarter should rise at around a 2.5 percent pace, even with another 20 percent plus drop in residential construction and only sluggish growth in consumer spending. While some analysts have been quick to jump the gun and declare that the U.S. economy is already in recession, we continue to believe such talk is foolish. Growth will most certainly slow over the next two quarters but we will see growth.
The biggest news this week was the stronger-than-expected third quarter productivity numbers, which showed nonfarm productivity climbing at a 4.9 percent annual rate. The gain was the largest in four years and brought the year-to-year change in nonfarm productivity growth back up to 2.4 percent, which is in line with its average for the past five years. Stronger productivity growth should help contain core inflation in coming months and will provide the Fed a little more breathing room to concentrate on offsetting the drag from the collapse of the subprime mortgage market.
Other major economic reports released this past week include a much larger than expected gain in both wholesale sales and inventories, which rose 1.3 percent and 0.8 percent respectively. Even if sales slow, there is plenty of room for inventories to rise, which should provide some downside protection to growth.
Weekly first-time unemployment claims also posted a surprising drop of 13,000 claims in early November. The better than expected unemployment data is a sign that conditions are stronger than widely believed outside the housing and mortgage finance sectors. With exports rising solidly, we think there is a good chance GDP growth will once again surprise us to the upside in coming months.
Global Review
As shown in the chart at the left, the dollar continued to get pounded this week. Comments by a Chinese official regarding the country’s foreign exchange reserves, which total an incredible $1.4 trillion, were one of the catalysts for this week’s sell-off (see top chart on page 4). The official said that China should favor strong currencies, which appeared to be a (not so?) subtle knock against the rapidly declining greenback. His comments helped to send the euro to yet another all-time high against the dollar. The official subsequently said he did not mean the Chinese government should buy more euros at the expense of dollars, but the damage had already been done.We have argued in the past that the Chinese government is not likely to dump its holdings of dollar assets. Mass selling of dollar securities would cause the greenback to tank and long-term interest rates to spike. The resulting financial market carnage could easily throw the U.S. economy into recession, an outcome in which China has little interest. A U.S. recession would lead to slower economic growth in China and softer labor market conditions. Rising unemployment has the potential to lead to social instability, which the government wants to avoid at all costs. Therefore, we view the probability of outright liquidation of U.S. assets by the Chinese government to be rather low.
Another pressing policy concern in China is the rise in inflation this year (see middle chart). Most of the run-up in the overall CPI this year reflects sharp increases in food prices. However, food makes up one-third of the Chinese CPI (the comparable figure in the United States is only 15%), so core CPI inflation could rise if workers demand higher wages to compensate for lost purchasing power. One way to help rein in inflationary pressures is currency appreciation, which helps to constrain import prices. As shown in the bottom chart, the pace of renminbi appreciation has picked up recently. Indeed, the Chinese currency strengthened 0.5% this week, the fastest rate of appreciation since the currency was revalued by 2% in July 2005. An added benefit to Chinese policymakers of faster currency appreciation is that it helps to keep Washington, which has been carping about the undervalued renminbi for years, off of their backs.
Are there any implications of euro appreciation for the Euro-zone? The biggest policy concern at the European Central Bank at present is inflation. Although the ECB opted to keep its main policy rate unchanged at 4.00% this week, ECB President Trichet said “the outlook for price stability over the medium term is subject to upside risks”. Will the ECB, which has been on hold since June hike rates again? We think not. Growth is slowing, and slower economic growth should cause inflationary pressures to dissipate.
Would the ECB cut rates to relieve the upward pressure on the euro versus the dollar? The ECB does not have a target for the exchange rate, so it would not ease policy simply because of the euro. If, however, currency appreciation leads to slower-than-expected growth and/or declining inflation, then the ECB would contemplate a rate cut. We do not believe the ECB is at that point yet. Rather than easing policy, the ECB might undertake currency market intervention if the euro should continue to strengthen.







