Texas Recovery is at Hand, but Clouds Remain

The drag from the U.S. and global recessions on the Texas economy appears to have abated. Most of the state’s key economic indicators have posted some improvement during recent months, even though most still remain well into negative territory on a year-to-year basis. We believe the recession ended around the middle of 2009 nationwide, and the Lone Star State appears to have turned the corner at about the same time. There are still plenty of storm clouds on the horizon, however. While the national economy saw exceptionally strong real GDP growth during the fourth quarter, much of that growth was due to a swing in business inventories, which is hard to isolate at the state level. That said, Texas is clearly seeing some short-term benefit from the massive fiscal and monetary stimulus put in place this past year. The real test, for both the nation and Texas, will be what happens once this stimulus winds down around the middle of the year? Texas is in better shape than any other large state and will likely post solid gains during the early stages of the recovery.

Texas Recession’s LIFO: Last In; First Out?

Texas entered the recession about nine months after the nation did according to the Texas Business Cycle Index (TBCI). Texas nonfarm employment declined shortly after oil prices collapsed during the second half of 2008. The price of West Texas Intermediate (WTI) petroleum topped out at around $142.00 per barrel around the Fourth of July 2008 and then tumbled to just over $32.00 per barrel around Christmas of that year. Prices for natural gas declined by an even greater magnitude and for a longer period of time. After hitting a high of $13.28 per million Btu (MMBtu) just before the Fourth of July 2008, prices began to tumble and eventually dropped below $2 per MMBtu just before Labor Day of 2009. Since then, prices bounced back a bit and averaged $5.13 per MMBtu in January.

Collapsing energy prices quickly translated into reduced exploration and production activity and it did not take long for employment to turn down. Texas nonfarm employment peaked in October 2008 and declined in 10 of the next 11 months, resulting in a cumulative net loss of around 350,000 jobs. The huge job losses that followed the plunge in energy prices underscore the severity of the economic downturn in Texas and expose the state’s still-heavy reliance on the energy sector. Oil and gas production have a huge multiplier effect, with the energy sector directly employing nearly a quarter million workers in Texas. The energy industry also fuels activity in key supplier industries, such as fabricated metals, and employs thousands of engineers and professional staff throughout the state.

There was more than an energy bust that brought down the Texas economy. Texas was also severely affected by the global financial collapse that followed the bankruptcy of Lehman Brothers in September 2008. Once credit markets seized up, home sales and residential construction plummeted. International trade, which had been a key source of growth leading up to the crisis, was abruptly thrown into reverse as trade credit became extremely hard to get. Moreover, the collapse in global economic growth weighed heavily on the state’s important manufacturing industry, particularly petrochemicals and consumer products.

Now that U.S. economic growth is picking up, will Texas emerge from this recession ahead of other states? We believe it will. Texas has avoided many of the most problematic aspects of the housing bust. Home prices rose less rapidly during the boom years and face less of a correction. The recession still produced a run-up in delinquency rates and foreclosures around the state, but far fewer Texans are underwater with their mortgages compared to other large, rapidly growing states. The latest data from First American Core Logic show that just 11.0 percent of Texas homeowners with a mortgage owe more than their home is currently worth versus 22.6 percent nationwide. Although Texas has a relatively large proportion of subprime loans, most are fixed-rate and delinquency rates are currently relatively low. In addition, only a small proportion of subprime and Alt-A mortgages will reset in Texas this year.