So – where do I get it wrong or what is it that I see and the others don’t? I don’t know - but I find it rather strange that so many are so sceptical to so many data releases.
I am used to US analysts being more optimistic to the US scenario than what is reality for the US economy. But them aside – this time around most analysts - anywhere - look to have that opinion.
Either I don’t get it, don’t understand it, is wrong or is simply stubborn. Or - is it because everyone is long USD and therefore talks in favour of their positon?
I stick to my own guts and maintain my view that the state of the US economy is not as good as everyone says. I will admit defeat when the figures show that I am wrong.
In fact I am more confident writing this today than early last week. I have read and twice re-read Janet Yellen’s “The Outlook for the Economy” at Rhode Island on Friday. She is not more dovish than before but she uses the expression “I hope” in terms of headwinds disappearing. She lists several of them and while she is optimistic that they will faint, she underlines that this is not certain to happen soon. I buy her arguments for the positive impact reduced unemployment have but she also addresses other aspects about the labour market not moving forward as fast as one had hoped.
She sees certain deteriorating data caused by “a variety of transitory factors”.
She repeated that she is optimistic the first rate hike will happen “at some point” this year. There were no mentioning of June or September but she said that “to support taking this step, she would need to see continued improvement in labour market conditions” and she would have to be “reasonably confident inflation will move back to 2% over the medium term”.
To be “sceptical to recent US data” as many have expressed they are, is generally not a strong argument. But in terms of US data one can justify the saying as they are often revised substantially over time. US GDP figures are revised twice after the initial release and monthly Non-Farm Payrolls are often revised several times. To be sceptical to recent data releases one likely can argue from historical facts. I buy that argument. The revisions though can go both ways should one not clearly be able to pin point why the first release is wrong.
I am focused on the two groups of data Janet Yellen mentioned as critical to her on Friday:
“Continued improvement in labour market conditions”: She wants to see unemployment getting lower, more people getting into employment, short-term contracts being extended, part-time employees moving into full-time employment, more upward pressure on wages and salaries and possibly longer working weeks.
Up against those “wishes” reality has been that services sectors have hired most of those in new jobs. Manufacturing sectors are struggling and public sectors do not have the mandate to employ more people. Services sectors make a living from selling products and services – predominantly domestically – especially when the USD shows strength. They are depending on higher confidence among businesses and consumers to continue investing in employees. Confidence is one thing – they also need to see retail sales picking up.
The latest data in terms of both confidence and retail sales show nothing in my view to trigger an optimistic outlook. It has been a puzzle to many that they have not picked up more than they have given the strong improvement in number of new employees. Why we are more positive to such improvements in the future than what reality has shown over the last two years is my question?
“Reasonably confident inflation will move back to 2% over the medium term”: Let’s focus on those data that are not including energy products – as they are outside the influence of monetary policies. I see only one source of higher inflation. Domestic demand has to pick up and for that to happen, all those labour market conditions Janet Yellen has in mind, have to improve.
It is predominantly consumer sectors that have to buy more to trigger price increases. For them to do so, they have to earn more and have confidence in their abilities to pay future expenses. What is it today or in the future that should trigger such higher abilities and confidence when that has not been the case over the last year or so? Again – I am interested in those arguments that can be based on facts and not on hopes. Even expectations based on “history repeating itself” are not good enough.
To conclude: Many of the data the Fed, FOMC and markets are looking for to improve, should have done so months ago. They didn’t and while a time-lag factor should be taken into account, it is now long overdue. To me it looks like there is something else happening to US consumers, investors and businesses’ behaviour, which we have not seen before in the aftermath of previous crisis. I cannot point out what it is but the lack of improvements makes me question whether there is something more fundamentally behind this and that those predictions USD central bankers, investors and long USD position holders do are more based on hope than a real understanding of what is happening to the US economy.
Hope never was and should never be something one should forecast from. To have both your feet into a heavy long USD exposure is not the best position to conduct a forecast either. But I can see the element of hope influencing them. It is also the reason I am sceptical to most US forecasts these days.
Recommended Content
Editors’ Picks
AUD/USD holds above 0.6500 in thin trading
The Australian Dollar managed to recover ground against its American rival after AUD/USD fell to 0.6484. The upbeat tone of Wall Street underpinned the Aussie despite broad US Dollar strength and tepid Australian data.
EUR/USD comfortable below 1.0800 lower lows at sight
The EUR/USD pair lost ground on Thursday and settled near a fresh March low of 1.0774. Strong US data and hawkish Fed speakers comments lead the way ahead of the release of the US PCE Price Index on Friday.
Gold pulls away from daily highs, holds above $2,200
Gold retreats from daily highs but holds comfortably above $2,200 in the American session on Thursday. The benchmark 10-year US Treasury bond yield stays near 4.2% after upbeat US data and makes it difficult for XAU/USD to gather further bullish momentum.
Google starts indexing Bitcoin addresses
Bitcoin address data is live on Google search results after users realized on Thursday that the tech giant started indexing Bitcoin blockchain data. However, mixed reactions have followed the tech giant's reversed stance on the cryptocurrency.
A Hollywood ending for fourth quarter GDP
The latest revisions put Q4 GDP at 3.4%, the second fastest quarterly growth rate in two years. Much of the upside was attributable to stronger consumer spending, yet fresh profits data affirmed it was a good quarter for the bottom line as well with profits up by the most since the Q2-2022.